It’s every boy’s dream to catch a ball at a baseball game. Most people don’t get the opportunity to do this, though — and if you’re this guy, you not only blow it, but cause a rift in your relationship that you likely won’t stop hearing about for some time.

This couple went to a baseball game when they saw a foul ball heading their direction. Thinking fast, the boyfriend went for it — and spilled his beer all over his girlfriend in the process. Say goodbye to those nachos (and any possibility of a quiet ride home).